Visual art exhibitions and events with a platform for critical writing
FeedbackInappropriate material?
Ideas? Technical issues?
» Feedback to a-n
By: Franny Swann
A record of my footsteps as I negotiate the projects that come my way.
My practice has evolved into interdisciplinary project work and I now call myself a multi-media project artist.
My work tends to be underpinned and referenced by memory and memorial; a citation to family members lost in the Holocaust.
It is important to me that within each project I solicit the freedom to be able to choose whichever media will best offer the viewer a multi layered narrative.
www.farninghamhobbyhorseproject.phanfare.com
[enlarge]
# 108 [30 September 2012]
Having met up with Clare Smith and posted a photo of her on my blog she has returned the compliment..hmm...bit like being tagged on Facebook - there you suddenly are looking parboiled and eerily grown up for some reason....
It was rather special to meet after following Clare's blog for years. Not something that has a parallel elsewhere in life really. Now it feels quite different when I read her blog. Connected of course. If we had been able to adjourn to the pub I think we would have talked all night.
Clare also introduced me to her DAD partner Joanna whose beautiful tempera abstracts were on the gallery wall. We too could have talked all night finding common interests in the first few seconds and only being silenced by the final bell.
Maybe we should organise a Christmas meet up in a London pub for all the a-n bloggers who fancy meeting their pen pals? Lunch time maybe so people had time to get there/ do other things/ meet other people....carnations in the button hole...
Perhaps others could do it in Liverpool/ Bristol....etc?
Elena's comment has made me think about the photos again....I find it hard to get past the Richter/Boltanski treatments which resonate with me.
I think its their respect and the subtlety.
Another barrier to buying vintage photos and seeing what comes is the fact that painting seems to be my instinctive reaction to the images....not sure why.
I haven't painted seriously for a long time. Also have exchanged my big studio for a small one so making a huge mess is now harder. Feels constrained before I have started.
Or me just making excuses. I know once I start a new road it becomes all consuming.
Bit like being on the diving board looking down.
Easier to keep wandering round the PV's for a while......
Then again I inherited a few tiny black and white negatives - most very damaged - of Berlin during the Nazi era.....hmm.....
Login to post a comment »
Comments on this post
yes, great idea
posted on 2012-10-05 by Clare Smith
That sounds like a wonderful idea to all meet up !!
posted on 2012-09-30 by Wendy Williams
[enlarge]
[enlarge]
[enlarge]
# 107 [29 September 2012]
My posts seems-to be morphing into a diary of time off art making, of wandering around its edges, of PV's, outings.....
I am certainly in a fallow, sit back and ponder phase. It all feels very autumnal. My Protestant work ethic little voice in the head keeps squeaking that I am not working, not producing, not progressing my career.
I am telling it to shut up.
Ideas swim in and out and things catch my attention - old photos seem to be high on the list - I have an inherited album of a post war European tour. Gerhard Richter swamps my field of vision here though and I don't seem to be able to get past him.
Nevertheless I do keep finding small sets of vintage photos in antique shops - obviously wrenched from old leather albums - and showing one family. They intrigue me these unknowns. Its the story telling aspect I think. Not sure how to tackle them and if I buy them I feel its a statement to mysef that I am not yet ready to fulfill.
So I wander on.....
Yesterday I went to the Hannah Peschar Sculpture Garden near Dorking. Two hours of peace and beauty. Great at this time of year; we had the place to ourselves and the duckweed had made some of the many ponds into extraordinary green silent otherworlds.
They will live in my memory longer than the work I think.
We met Hannah Peshar in the reception building - charming and chatty she has been building the huge 'wild' garden for 30 years. I do so envy people who have been able to dedicate their life to something like this....
So - green and dripping woods, magical ponds and other peoples black and white images.....
It all feels like overload and no straight line to a new body of work at present. But that's ok for now.
Login to post a comment »
Comments on this post
Other people's old photos hold more fascination than my own. I know about the people in my own. It's the history thing again, strands of unattached memory flailing about in junk shops and car boot sales. I want to know what broke in order for these to end up being sold? These are the things that people would at one time have rescued from a burning building. And in 50 yrs time, they wont be replaced, because of the digital versions. I want to know where the clothes ended up. What happened to the shiny shoes and the hair ribbons? Buy the photos... re-attach them to something new.
posted on 2012-09-30 by Elena Thomas
Hi Franny, I was just about to close down my laptop and get on with 'proper' life when your post came through. Glad I read it - an utterly uplifting post & sums up perfectly for me how we should all just maybe relax a bit more. The sculpture garden will have probably fed the soul for future work and relaxation like this must be infinitely better for you than thinking too hard. It was only last week that you were involved in a really well-received event in Hastings I remember. A good idea, then to tell that Protestant work ethic to hush I think :)
posted on 2012-09-29 by Kate Murdoch
[enlarge]
# 106 [27 September 2012]
On Tuesday evening Ros Barker and I attended a West Kent Reception for the great and the good. All dressed up and being very grown up we soon found we were the only arts related invitees and we were definitely short of a chain of office or an OBE. Still, we met some interesting people who seemed relieved to have the chance of a different type of conversation.
Tonight was the PV of 'The Meeting Room: A Space for Minds to Meet' - the new show in the Kaliedoscope Gallery in Sevenoaks.
'The Meeting Room explores the meeting point between the physical and the metaphysical....'
In amongst some really lovely work were three drawings on Chinese paper: small but holding the wall they were hung on. A red line grid held endless downward black strokes within its squares. It had a stillness and a fascination ..each handmade stroke quivering with the life of different widths and darkness.
All the work of Clare Smith - who made the long trip from Dover to be there. Although feeling I had known her for ages through the a-n blog, we actually met for the first time tonight.
Lots to talk about. Good old a-n....
Login to post a comment »
Comments on this post
Have posted pic of you and Ros on my blog!
posted on 2012-09-30 by Clare Smith
Good morning Franny thanks so much for this! I enjoyed meeting you and Ros and hope to see you again soon.
posted on 2012-09-28 by Clare Smith
[enlarge]
[enlarge]
[enlarge]
# 105 [25 September 2012]
I am just putting my head back over the parapet having struggled to get to the stage when I could get to my blog.
Huge family party has taken all my energy and focus away from everything else. Finally getting to the stage when I have returned house/garden/ my psyche back to a semblance of normaility and have time to look back at the Telling Stories Private View - which happened in the middle of the madness...
A lovely evening [before the rains set in] which we needed as the evening was started by the arrival of the Urban Bikes which rode up from Hastings town to open the show for us.They continued to arrive during the evening - decked out with lights and soundscapes.It all felt inclusive and great fun. A great scene setter.
The event was massively well attended - at some points you could hardly move. So much so that I feel the need to go back and see the show again, in peace.
It was the first show where I hadn't been involved in the hang in any way. Strange to come in and find your familiar work in an unfamiliar enviroment. Cathryn Kemp the TS curator and Sue the museum curator had hung the exhibition and it looked considered and classy. A show to be proud of.
Halfway through the evening Youmeni who is a Japenese performance artist danced for us in the darkness of the fabulous Dunbar Room. She told the story of the family kimono she was wearing, her exquisite movements speaking of searing emotion and pain. She must have been physically and emotionally exhausted.
Various speeches ensued but the Art Council England speech was amazing - he really got us a group and made a big point of saying he regarded TS as a standard of excellence. Can't ask for more really.
So - show hung and PV done.
One of the TS artists has asked if I would like to join a new group of women artists considering world wide womens issues from a feminist viewpoint.
A great set of artists I would like to know better and maybe work with...another new door opens. Brilliant.
Login to post a comment »
Comments on this post
I'm sorry we didn't get together Kate...look forward to next time.... Images are on a very basic old digital Canon - seems to do it all for me...I can even get drunk - it has anti- shake!!
posted on 2012-09-27 by Franny Swann
Circumstances prevailed against me & I didn't make it, I'm afraid. Just about everyone I met during the day in Hastings however appeared to be making their way to the Museum that evening so I'm not at all surprised that the place was packed. Beautiful images of your work and what a lovely compliment 'standard of excellence' is - congratulations.
posted on 2012-09-27 by Kate Murdoch
Congratulations Franny! Great to see some stunning images from the show.
posted on 2012-09-27 by Jean McEwan
[enlarge]
# 104 [20 September 2012]
Have just got back from London having been on a evening tour of the College of Arms - at the opposite end of the Millenium Bridge from Tate Modern.
My head is now full of vellum and quill ink, strange heraldic animals, medieval colours, 15th century leather bound books and the smell of old archives......
Maybe I could live in there?
Maybe they need a resident artist?
Login to post a comment »
Comments on this post
ask them!
posted on 2012-09-22 by Elena Thomas
[enlarge]
# 103 [18 September 2012]
My previous blog seems to have sparked some discussion on gender difference. It followed a crit that I took part in during which the work offered was criticised for being 'too emotional'.
Intrigued, I have mentioned it at discussions with various artist groups. Each time it seemed to ellicit an immediate response and has sparked some discussion in my comment box here too.
So - following David Minton pointing out he was short of information - here it is.
An image of the work in question is attached.
It is a broken vintage display box with a glass front containing a shoe sole and parts of shoe soles. These were beachcombed and are heavily textured with barnacles, salt crystals and age.
The work is monochrome. It is domestic in size and nature.
It was offered to the crit group with a title - 'I Let Go your Hand.'
...and yes- the instigator of the original 'too emotional' crit discussion WAS a male artist but in my subsequent chats I hadn't mentioned that; it was always just asssumed - which is interesting.
Listening to some in the crit group I got the feeling that clean, clear concepts and work were felt to be 'correct' and anything entering the realms of the poetic or dealing with the personal emotional [unless political or dark] was somehow suspect.
Relating this story has lead to other artists linking this to a patriarchcal overview they blamed on a currently male dominated art scene.
Personally I think the title may have something to do with it. Without the 'emotional' title attached maybe the feedback would have been different?
My work is always linked to memory and memorial and often to a family history of loss in the Holocaust. I tend to work in museological formats; curating archivings of loss.
Titles are always a minefield.
In this case I felt very strongly that it had to be titled - although I wouldn't go as far as revealing what drove me to make the work. I believe an audience needs the space to project on to a work. Probably my title has already stolen some of that space.....
So - that's the work.
Can a work be too emotional? I guess eventually it becomes a form of Kitsch.
Maybe it just means that the viewer has had an emotional response to it and dislikes the fact - maybe even feeling tricked into it in some way?
Are we as artists being set up to feel that 'emotion' in work will in some way fail at the last hurdle of greatness and should therefore be avoided? That it is a weakness and not a strength in a contemporary piece of art.
If so - is this coming through the curators, funders, arts officers?
I doubt it comes through the gallerists. Emotion always sells.
Login to post a comment »
Comments on this post
I've found myself looking at work over the past few days, and trying to work out initial reactions along the lines of male/female: emotional/unemotional. Either trying to guess the artist, or pin down my response... silly, fruitless game, with impossible venn diagram. But I have been thinking about David's and Franny's work - have you shown your work together? I know you have met/know each other. I do have similar responses to your work. There is the stillness, sadness, hope, delicacy, life and death... beauty in the ugliest of places in the mind... these things, when I see the work, that is common to you both.
posted on 2012-09-22 by Elena Thomas
Hi Thank you all for taking the time.... Elena I am really interested in what you said about the museum style as control...I have been told that before but its not in my head as I work. I should think about it again I think. David - I had forgotten that you had seen the work, which makes your comments different again. You are right - emotion is a catch all term. Can also be positive or derogatory .... Ruth - Hi! Hmm..........right up your street. Maybe I should take up pink?
posted on 2012-09-19 by Franny Swann
Gosh this sounds like familiar territory...so good to see you having the discussion.
posted on 2012-09-19 by Ruth Geldard
Hello Franny, The most interesting aspect of the previous comments was the assumption of the male, especially in a context which questions patriarchy, where the one thing to avoid perhaps is behaviour that might be described as ‘patriarchal.’ I wonder too if the use of the term ‘emotional ’does the work a disservice, in that it (the work) triggers a flow of feelings that are powerful because subtle - I have seen it. ‘Emotion’ is too much a catch-all term; kitsch in some contexts simply releases cheap feeling.
posted on 2012-09-19 by David Minton
ooh Franny.... can of worms! first of all, your work appeals to me because it is emotional. Even if I didn't know the "back story" the items you use, the way you display them is emotional. The museum style I see as a means of control, a way of being emotionally literate, to recognise, categorise, and attempt to move on. And this is what I love. To me, art about life is always going to be better than art about art. The gender thing... hmm.... we still live in a world, even to the west of Europe, where the majority of people in higher positions are men. We are in a patriarchal society, and the structure of it is male orientated. Unless we start completely from scratch, that's not really going to change, we just have to adjust things as we go along, highlighting unfairnesses as we go along, then bolting the solution on to what we already have. The MA process I have just been through, with its culture of crit and analysis has not shown me that emotional is a bad thing...phew!... but that a lack of awareness is a bad thing. If you know what you are doing and why, then carry on, regardless of sex/gender.
posted on 2012-09-19 by Elena Thomas
[enlarge]
# 102 [17 September 2012]
All the way down to Hastings again today....to take the work to the Hastings Museum and Gallery.
Discovered that the museum curator had chosen part of one of my images for a huge poster at the gate. Brilliant.
Wonder what they do with them afterwards? Mind you I think it could be wrapped twice around my studio, so no idea where I would put it....
and someone had to point it out to me...so big I missed it.
Login to post a comment »
Comments on this post
wow amazing Franny! if it was my work I'd paper my wall with it after!
posted on 2012-09-18 by Elena Thomas
[enlarge]
[enlarge]
# 101 [15 September 2012]
Another great day out....down to Hastings to join the QR code walk around the town. Neil and Dan from Zeroh lead the walk - they having been responsible for implementing the project on behalf of Telling Stories.
The QR codes were creative and beautiful - some featuring fabulous videos paralleling the work to be exhibited in TS.
Walking through the town we came upon a past Zeroh project. The Moth Project took stencils and rainwater and created 'reverse graffiti' on grimy walls. The results were hauntingly lovely and are still good even two years later.
Ambling along the seafront with the sea and the sun and chatting art stuff with other artists was a joy.
Reporting on a crit I took part in I was saying that I was concerned by the feedback that the work I showed was 'too emotional.' This produced some discussion as to why this seems to be the case at the moment. We are not talking sweet or even figurative here - in fact the work in question is monochrome found objects in a vintage box.
It was shown to the crit with an 'emotional' title attached....maybe the feedback would have been different without it. Today there was some discussion around the patriarchcal overview of a male dominated art scene. The feeling being that clean, clear concepts and work was felt to be correct and anything entering the realms of the poetic or dealing with the personal emotional [unless political or dark] was somehow suspect.
Is this so? Are the majority of arts officers, curators, Arts Council.... male appointments?
Login to post a comment »
Comments on this post
Have just read Elena’s latest comment. Watching my boy and girl grandchildren grow is threatening my lefty prejudices against gender generalisations. We do SEEM to be different, to coin some capitals, but I will resist absolute surrender. Gender is a work in progress. Feminine/masculine is gender, female/male is sexual? Boundaries are coercive?
posted on 2012-09-18 by David Minton
Smartarse comment and now I have to think about it!! Serves me right for jumping so quickly. ‘Too emotional’ without knowing the full context, might be a legitimate comment or a crass reaction. There is no indication that the comment was made by someone apparently male, as is assumed in the other comments. My weeping chap has his tongue in his cheek. I just felt that us guys were all being painted from the one bucket of tar. Gender I think is now a much more fluid concept than it has been. Montpelier 1 - Arsenal 2. Up the lads!!
posted on 2012-09-18 by David Minton
The question of male appointments is what prompted the comment about a gender difference. I think there probably is a difference, because we ARE different. I don't think my work is gender neutral, I know for a fact it is feminine/female in nature. The men I have talked to about my work recently do see it differently to the women, but I would expect that to be the case, but not all of the women have had an emotional response, and some of the men have. I think it is interesting to be aware, and to notice. But they are just differences, neither is better/worse than another. This is why in the fields you mention Franny, it is crucial there is an equality in the appointments made I think, across the board.
posted on 2012-09-18 by Elena Thomas
Ahh.... Please not to forget that actually I haven't commented!......also that I think your work and mine understands eachother very well ... Is your double question mark there because you think gender difference in what we choose to work on, how we chose to offer the work and how we percieve the finished object is basically gender neutral? Or are you just fed up with the whole debate?
posted on 2012-09-18 by Franny Swann
Enough to make a chap weep! Gender difference??
posted on 2012-09-18 by David Minton
Hi Franny Just read your last blog post and was intrigued and a little horrified by comments your work was 'too emotional'. I may have missed some context from previous posts but this seems like a massively dismissive pretty stupid and yes more than likely misogynistic comment to make about another artist's work. I hope you are not discouraged. Take no notice. Make it MORE emotional! There is no correct way. Its ART. Sometimes other artists can be w*****s. Keep faith! x
posted on 2012-09-17 by Jean McEwan
If work I see or for that matter, work I do, elicits an emotional response, I feel it is successful. That I can express an idea by taking an item, and making marks upon it; people look at it, their eyes carry a signal to their brain and it makes them feel something they didn't before looking at it... How magical, mysterious and wonderful is that? Maybe there is a gender difference in what is appreciated... but an emotional response? That'll do for me!
posted on 2012-09-15 by Elena Thomas
[enlarge]
[enlarge]
# 100 [14 September 2012]
Lots of PVs around at the moment...... or Opening Nights as the more PC version now seems to be.
Yesterday I drove to Battle and the Pure Art Fair PV because Ros Barker - my Farningham Hobby Horse partner- was showing new work. She had won the best drawing prize; so much hugging and congratulating.
Lots of artists I knew and some to catch up with from several years ago....a long drive but an easy, chatty evening. Art Fairs are not really on my radar at the moment so I felt a rather detached observer.
Working the way I do - wanting all my works to have a dialogue with eachother within one space - it does seem very odd to jump from one work to another and have them butted up against one another with the inevitable problems. That is not to say that the hang wasn't good - it was. Just that it's an impossible job to give work its own space unless you have a huge space.
This evening couldn't have been more different. I was in Dartford Park for the launch of the Ecology of Colour by Studio Weave. It is an Artlands Project. I love their projects and this didn't disappoint.
Built on Ecology Island within Dartford Central Park a sustainable building has arisen - its use will be open ended but will begin with workshops and performance.
Lovely to be outside in the wood, by a stream and with the light fading. Brilliant food - amazing - and with the chance to make plaster casts and natural dye prints. We all had to have a go of course and the results were spectacular. Nicolette Goff who was leading the workshop managed to get us to produce the most beautiful embossed prints with just blueberry juice, found vegetation and her book press. Magic.
I have done three projects in Dartford Central Park in the past, so its close to my heart.
Tempted to come up with a proposal ...
Login to post a comment »
[enlarge]
[enlarge]
# 99 [10 September 2012]
It seems to be a time of endings at the moment.
Ros and I took the Farningham Hobby Horse Project out for the last time on Saturday. Beautiful weather and the usual lovely crowd. We should have been returning the horses to their makers but we had to negotiate with them to hold on to their horses until November as we have now been asked by a curator if we would be willing to exhibit them at an Olympic art event.
All done; so we wait to see how many will be required.
The Q codes that are presently up around Hastings will be going to the Harbour Arm Gallery, Margate at the beginning of October to form the nucleus of a new show that will run alongside 'Telling Stories:Hastings.'
Now to decide what supporting work to show alongside it.
I am tempted to send my wasps in the test tubes that I bought in Margate. How to show them? After a long hunt I finally tracked down some tiny tool clips thinking I would attach them to board; but I am not sure. Have been Googling test tube holders...not quite right either. I need to work this out and get on with it. Maybe I should just drive around a lot - I think well in the car.
Login to post a comment »
Comments on this post
For one wonderful moment I read it as nose clips!!
posted on 2012-09-11 by Franny Swann
http://www.screwfix.com/p/hose-clips-20-32mm-pack-of-10/46961?cm_sp=Search-_-SearchRec-_-Area2&_requestid=20967 screwfix are my best mates! what about these?
posted on 2012-09-11 by Elena Thomas