What follows in this final post from my Open Engagement 2018 residency in New York are a series of responses, provocations & quotes from a keynote given by Lucy Lippard. When I posted my first questions onto this blog, prior to travelling, I had many lofty questions related to sustainability. It seems Lucy has managed to encapsulate their answers succinctly …enjoy, consider, reflect.

  • For years we’ve been warning against artists ‘parachuting’ into unfamiliar territory.
  • Socially involved Art Workers, like everybody else, have to choose among the tsunami of issues around sustainability that we should be weighing in on, fighting for. But sometimes it feels like we are spread so thin that we will blow away. As a South-Westerner my list is headed by climate change, water, indigenous rights, saving public lands and the heartbreaking fates of the youthful undocumented immigrants of DACA (Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals) whose lives have been put in terrible limbo because they had the courage to risk their futures by speaking out against unfair immigration policies.
  • Confronted by this endless list we have to focus, hard as it may be, to choose. We have to ask ourselves ‘What do we want to say and how do we want to say it and to whom?’
  • Of course the rest of the endless litany is equally important: racism, poverty, incarceration, guns, #metoo, #timesup, homophobia, police brutality, Middle Eastern wars and Palestinian rights, deadly pollution on land and sea, the toll of fossil fuel extraction, race, gender, class, religion. What did I miss?
  • Suzanne Lacy, who is my longtime Social Practice mentor, say she works at the intersection of community, development and visual art; she talks about creating ‘Citizen Artists’. She’s a genius at contextualising non-Art contexts, at choreographing collective expression and bringing unheard voices to the foreground; if not exactly the centre.
  • These days Lacy’s planning for a solo show at the San Fransisco Museum and she’s struggling over how to create visual impact in a museum while maintaining authenticity within the community. She says ‘The Art World is where I get to TALK, the Community is where I get to LISTEN.’
  • Suzanne has said if she hadn’t been interested in addressing the Art World she would have gone into politics and she credits Allan Kaprow with showing her the advantages of putting LIFE into the GALLERY and putting the GALLERY into LIFE. She talks about not starting with an idea but arriving at the idea as it’s generated by those at the table.
  • A recent panel in Santa Fe on Feminism and Intersectionality emphasised ‘Radical Inclusiveness’ and made several points about entering a community that is not our own:

– Take part but don’t take-the-lead. 

– Curiosity is good but not voyeurism. 

– Honesty is good, condescension isn’t.

– You cant fake empathy.

  • Have we educated ourselves about unfamiliar cultures? Listen. Do they want our help? Who are they and who are we? Shouldn’t it be just ‘we’?
  • Artists working ‘in’ communities have to work ‘with’ communities and sometimes social success means aesthetic sacrifice.
  • We are still a long way from achieving the gender and racial fluidity that we’ve begun to contemplate in recent decades. Black Lives Matter has changed the dialogue and upped-the-ante just as #MeToo and #TimesUp are resurrecting Feminist issues and some real soul-searching about ‘whiteness’.
  • There’s no question that we need ‘thicker skins’ in order to really understand racism within our society. I’m always torn between staying safe, focusing on what I know, and venturing into areas where I may not be welcome and my ignorance will be exposed. I’m not entirely sure why the terms Multiculturalism and Identity Politics are so discredited (I know the Right Wing has had a lot to do with it) since they are terms that lead to a consideration of diversity, hybridity, cross-overs and ‘intersectionality’ – the favourite terms these days for working across boundaries, and even across walls.
  • In the last few years groups formally perceived as voiceless have stood up and finally been heard. Indigenous people at Standing Rock and in the Idle No More movement, have raised consciousness not only about pipelines, clean water and treaty rights but suddenly the Art World knows something about Indians…which is rare.

Q: What do we want to SUSTAIN? 

Certainly not the status quo! Western-so-called-Civilisation? ALL Civilisation? How about the entire planet and everything on it? How do we do that? We as a society are JUST beginning to understand that Social Sustainability is inextricably linked to Ecological Sustainability, which is a basic necessity for survival, and for Public Practice Art. Like Public Practice, sustainability is dependent on empathy and down-sizing, both of which are hard to achieve in a racist, capitalist society based entirely upon unsustainable growth, non-stop-for-profit-expansion and to-Hell with the consequences. Growth of everything from mansions to nuclear arsenals to strip-mines to corporate conglomerates to ever-larger-and-more-expensive-installations and artworks. 

  • E.F.Schumacher’s influential 1973 book ‘Small is Beautiful – Economics as if People Mattered’ occupies a small but beautiful place in our pantheon. In this country ‘small’ is no longer just ‘beautiful’ its CRUCIAL. It’s not just a matter of tiny houses, urban in-fill, biking, resource conservation, environmental protection, recycling and planned parenthood. It’s a psychological impetus that is needed EVERYWHERE. Downsize or die. Halt or at least ‘slow’ growth until some sort of sustainable justice for both PEOPLE and the PLANET is reached.
  • Let’s take a moment, this moment, to salute organic growth. It’s Spring, seeds are sprouting, and a lot of you are just beginning your activist lives.
  • When we are talking about ‘inclusivity’, about uniting whole communities, the bigger the scale, the broader the reach the better. Part of downsizing for socially engaged and Eco Artists is conceiving of ones art within a context of unsustainable resources like water and fossil fuels. Building towards the future instead of planning for posterity, spending time in our own communities. We are still searching for our Post-Capitalist self. An alternative to the rugged individualism of manifest destiny. An alternative that allows working people a decent living and human rights, which are, alas, rapidly being downsized.
  • I have great faith in small-scale projects that have potential to spread into much larger spheres.
  • The strongest Public Practice, like Activism, starts from a specific location, from consciously ‘lived’ experience. But it as to move-on-out from there in a kind of ripple effect. If you don’t know your ‘hood’ you’re likely to idealise or disparage its inhabitants, fail to recognise threats or choose the wrong solutions as the basis of your Art.

Q: So, where do you live? What’s your centre? How far out do the ripples go? Are you ‘following’ or are you remaining at the centre and holding the reins? Are there other Artists? Community members with whom you may have little in common until you forge alliances over issues that effect everyone? Who do you live with? Dispossessed locals, deracinated newcomers, grumpy landowners, Artists, opioid addicts, rich part-timers, stray dogs, abandoned horses, feral cats, threatened wildlife, too damn many bunnies?

  • For some of us the best way to deal with the onslaught of urgent issues is in trying to strengthen our local community.
  • A concentration upon PLACE, which cant be conflated with land, site or landscape, can bring EVERYTHING into focus, including politics.
  • I’ve heard from friends coming from generations of deracination, (they are often Jewish, but also Middle Eastern, African & Asian) that it’s often hard to work with rooted communities when one can identify no ‘home’ place of ones own. I insisted in a 1998 book called ‘The Lure of the Local’ that wherever we find ourselves, even for short periods, we have to take responsibility for that place as long as were are there. I talk about ‘senses of place’ (plural)… it’s a much better idea than a sense-of-place, I mean, there isn’t just one. Listening to the stories of long term occupants of the place we live and work is one way of knowing ‘where’ we’ve landed for however short or long a time.

Q: How can Artists help change the way humans relate to nature and to each other? 

We share DNA with every form of life on the planet. It’s not too late for humanity to consider the legal right of nature herself. Indigenous people are demanding rights for nature and for themselves, from India to Ecuador to New Zealand where a 400,000 acre National Park taken from the Maori’s has been designated as a ‘person’ not property. Land belongs to itself; what a concept!

Nature, which of course include ‘us’ should not be a commodity that we can sell off to the highest bidder. It’s a community we belong to and harm at our own risk. 

  • Pollution causes three times a many death as AIDS, malaria and tuberculosis combined.
  • The blip-in-time that is the human race will not be missed but we’ll miss ‘us’ a lot. Everything’s coming-down-the-pipe far faster than we imagined it could. I used to worry about my grandsons and future generations down-the-line. Now I worry about my son, who is in his early 50’s.
  • As things race out-of-control and we do nothing as we destroy our environment, run out of water, witness species extinction and climate change and so forth, we should know that similar catastrophes have happened to the planet many times before.
  • This era, called the Athropocene since 2000 is also dubbed the Misanthopocene or Anthromosaic. An era of loneliness and isolation as species go extinct and desertification increases, as the oceans rise and the ground waters sink. The sense of urgency is so overwhelming it can stop us in our tracks and make us hide our heads in the sand – which by the way is another endangered material.
  • Sea level around Manhattan is projected to rise 6ft with this century. Huge cities can’t build a wall the way the wealthy do to protect their seaside Summer homes! As we know from East and West Germany, Israel, Palestine and the US/Mexico border – WALLS ARE NOT THE ANSWER.
  • It’s coming down to a race between HUMANS and CLIMATE CHANGE to see who can get rid of us first. George Orwell said in his dystopian book, 1984:



  • Artists can create history and challenge it by telling stories of resilience that give us hope and courage. Some of us advocate destruction of offensive monuments to evil-doers others recommend their removal to museums as artefacts of an unlamented past.
  • I retain my admiration for that ultimate in eye-opening Feminist truisms: THE PERSONAL IS POLITICAL AND (FOR ITS SIGNIFICANT OTHER) THE POLITICAL IS PERSONAL. These remain living and dynamic propositions. A brilliant way to translate lived-experience, positive and negative, into political consciousness. They ‘open’ ways to understand ‘others’ experiences. When we know our family histories, and those of our neighbours, and of our lands, ’who’ and ‘where’ we are in a political and historical sense, we are far better equipped to be compassionate and collaborative within a time-and-place we all share.
  • Ultimately words and images offer ways to integrate our own imaginings of life into those of a polity.
  • The relationship of imagination to reality and action is crucial, especially for Artists and Writers who specialise in acting in the gap between ‘two’, or between art and life. If we lean too far on the imagination side we risk falling off the edge into wishful-thinking, like ‘Visualise World Peace’ then we fall back onto the couch! Lean too far onto the reality side and we risk getting so discouraged that we get stuck in the status-quo.
  • We Art Workers have always had to be satisfied with small victories, with raising consciousness rather than raising politics or changing policies. Sometimes we fool ourselves about how successful our projects can be. Yet every one of us has some faith in Art as a way of inspiring, or even jolting, or even just pin-pricking people out of their self-imposed or received stupors. Of adding visual layers to the global debates. I always say that Art Workers can’t change the World but with the right allies little miracles can happen. Well maybe not miracles, but a lot of hard work, catalysing a generation, hanging-in there.
  • We need to discuss the failures as often as the successes. These times call for some tough-love and honesty with ourselves and our colleagues because being effective seems more crucial today than at any time I can remember, and i’ve been messing with this for some 60 years.

Once again…

Q: What do we want to say and how do we want to say it? Where do we go from here?   

A: I hope you haven’t been holding your breathe for answers to all these questions cos-I-ain’t-got’em! But these questions are directed as much at me as they are at you. Personally the temptation to be cynical, nasty and bridge-burning can be overwhelming. But that puts us in the same bag as the opposition. There’s a line between skepticism and cynicism. Somebody said pessimism is a waste of time and optimists are ‘dissed’ as utopian woo-woo, and politically reactionary. It’s true that we need to be down-to-earth but we also need to have something to hope for, something to reach for.

I hardly ever give a talk without citing Antonio Gramsci:


…I don’t think it has ever been better said.

Thank you.

Lucy Lippard

Queens Museum / 12th May 2018 / New York / Open Engagement 2018


Further resources:






Artist / Practitioners:

Melanie Crean


Shaun Leonardo


  • 16 – 24 yr olds who’ve been arrested. A 4 week cycle, which after completion, the judgement is erased
  • PTSD origins – when a physical response is separated from language cognition
  • Both lofty and practical responses
  • – It’s easier to describe a traumatic event if you picture yourself removed from the event. This leaves out your own subjectivity….and distances you from your own emotion. 
  • NB: For a storyteller (the person sharing a narrative) it’s often more important /potent for a truth to be played out in front of themselves by another. 
  • When you portray something through the LISTENER the STORYTELLER often learns something new EMOTIONALLY 
  • Patterns of social trauma
  • Methods:
  • SILENT MINIMAL GESTURE = embodiment 
  • CONCRETE UNIVERSAL = the emotional for, or centre, of the narrative
  • PHYSICAL NARRATIVE = speech isn’t always necessary. Physical re-embodiment or patterning 
  • EXTERNALISATION = to take it beyond yourself, your body. The generosity of embodiment; to take care on a human level
  • Memory forensics
  • Crowdsourcing memory 



MEL CHIN / Keynote


Bio: Mel Chin was born in Houston, Texas in 1951. Chin’s art, which is both analytical and poetic, evades easy classification. He is known for the broad range of approaches in his art, including works that require multi-disciplinary, collaborative teamwork and works that conjoin cross-cultural aesthetics with complex ideas.


  • Get ready to be confronted by your own history – your own inadequacy. I don’t think it’s always joyful sometimes it’s extremely painful. Be aware you’re dealing with other human beings and their lives. It’s always changing.


  • Our world has been transformed by covert military practices


  • In response to (Katrina) disasters: When tragedy at this level occurs the whole world loses… as Artists we have to show solidarity, we have to continue.


  • Do not track down disasters to make art. That’s ambulance chasing bullshit


  • Research to DESTROY your pre-conceived notions


  • ART is a HUMANISING process


  • The greatest gift that you can give IS TO GIVE. That’s human ‘BEING’


  • It’s not about inspiration it’s about what you are COMPELLED to do… Sometimes ya gotta be artsy-crafty, sometimes disgruntled, sometime you advertise the reality. Don’t do it for the recognition. Put anonymous things in anonymous places.




  • Sometimes an ideas comes within 30 seconds


  • Use the power of the collective voice, amassed, and take it to the legislators who have the power. Give them the avenues to own the project and take it forward


  • You have to roll with the conditions you are given on a daily basis. Failures are sometimes temporary


  • I have no prescription, signature or style.


  • Art is not about the end-goal but about the catalytic structure…


  • You have to be engaged enough to care…


  • There is an ecology to the actions you are engaged within…


  • Think of project as the ‘blue-print’ for other things…it’s a way of recalibrating…think of it as REALITY THERAPY


  • Innuit: ‘I see our way of life, thousands of years old, facing storms we cannot read’


Field Notes:
On Justice & Practice
Date: 10th May, 2018

Location: The Grace Rainey Rogers Auditorium, The Metropolitan Museum of Art of New York


Framing the Work: Philanthropic Partnerships 


Dana Zucker / Exec Director Gray Foundation


Dorian Brown / Assistant Exec Director The William R. Kenan, Jr Charitable Foundation


Chair: Sandra Jackson-Dumont Frederick P. and Sandra P. Rose Chairman of Education




  • This is a time to be appropriately agitated. We are developing a community of thinkers to critically engage with their lives.
  • To those who much is given much is expected
  • The Met talks of an ‘Ecosystem Practice’ 
  • Q: How should we ‘show-up-and-care’ for the people we work with?



  • Art is the way in which we speak to one another …it’s not an add-on. It is core to the culture of who we are.
  • We have to re-position where philanthropic institutions are situated by shifting from thinking about broken individuals to working on the broken systems that serve those individuals. 
  • This is not about creating new structures to impose upon a community. It is about find the community tables that already exist. 
  • From an infrastructure perspective: It’s about bringing a good programme into a good policy so that you can scale-it-up. 
  • Empathy is required for JUSTICE TO FLOURISH.
  • First Responders are Artists



  • We weren’t interested in creating a bureaucracy or another set of rules …we were interested in making changes to the communities we serve.
  • It’s really difficult to dis-aggregate the arts from anything we do.


The Artists Voice 

Three socially engaged artists discuss their varying practices, the role of the public in their work, and their relationship with institutions and communities

Moderated by Maricelle Robles

Educator in Charge, Public Programmes and Engagement, The Met


Chloe Bass:


  • Everyday quotidian dynamics
  • CITY def: ‘More people living better together’
  • Sustaining relationships > scales of intimacy > WAR is very intimate

Rashida Bumbray:


  • Call and Response work
  • The Art worlds systems and philanthropy do not support sustainability.

Miguel Luciano:


  • Representation and Absence 
  • Challenging military borders by flying kites over boundaries 
  • Projects as ‘exercises for deeper connections’
  • Cultural Pride as an Expression of Resistance 



Hank Willis-Thomas / Keynote


  • Employing imagination as a tool 
  • Ambiguity is what makes art legible and eternal 
  • There is a network but most of our network doesn’t seem to know each other.
  • Thinking as artists as Civic Leaders
  • ‘Moving’ the world through COURAGE and SENSITIVITY
  • Integrity is always in balance when we make work and when we work with other people
  • As if the air and water care about the borders people have been crossing for millennia 



On Saturday 5th May I attended:

Bring Down The Walls

‘Creative Time, in partnership with The Fortune Society, is proud to present Bring Down The Walls, a three-part public art project with artist Phil Collins in collaboration with over 100 individuals and organizations.

Setting the stage for Bring Down The Walls, this first week we look at the origins of the prison industrial complex, inviting global, historical and personal perspectives that question how and why our current culture of systemic control and punishment exists. Conversations will introduce the abolitionist position, as well as explore the intrinsic links between the current prison system and America’s history of racial exploitation, economic discrimination, and other oppressive social practices.’

The event was the first scheduled activity of my professional development residency and it enabled me to focus on the following question from my bursary-application:

‘How can we ensure that an ethics of environmental symbiosis and equality amongst all peoples is not only sustained, but updated and informed by future generations?’

• ‘Notes on the Afterlife of Mass Incarceration’ was particularly fascinating in terms of equality from the perspective of incarcerated ethnic community members. The audience was encouraged to rethink the inevitability of the ‘revolving door’ by considering the inherent potential for prison to manifest a series of ‘RADICAL SPACES FOR FREEDOM’ for prisoners in correctional institutions.

Dr Reuben Jonathan Miller presented a ‘framework’ for transformation, from an engagement perspective, that promoted process-lead interactions as follows:





MOVING FROM THE REJECTION OF THE ‘OTHER’ (Making people the ‘vector’ of all of your fears) to the creation of RADICAL SPACES OF FREEDOM and EMBODIMENT.

Bio: Reuben Jonathan Miller is an ethnographer and Assistant Professor in the University of Chicago School of Social Service Administration. His research examines life at the intersections of race, poverty, crime control, and social welfare policy. His forthcoming book, titled Halfway Home, is based on 15 years of research and practice with currently and formerly incarcerated individuals and their communities.

• Baz Dreisinger talked about correctional institutions  being ‘Factories of suffering for human beings that offer up pockets of radical progressiveness AND radical backwardness’

Bio: Dr. Baz Dreisinger is the founder and Academic Director of the Prison-to-College Pipeline program, which offers college courses and reentry planning to incarcerated men throughout New York State. Dr. Dreisinger was named a 2017-2018 Global Fulbright Scholar for her work promoting education and restorative justice and her book Incarceration Nations: A Journey to Justice in Prisons Around the World, was named a Notable Book of 2017 by the Washington Post.

Phil Collins and Vocalists from Bring Down the Walls (benefit album) discussed the power of ‘music as an unlocking mechanism’ which was echoed by Michael Austin (who spent 27 yrs wrongfully incarcerated for murder and robbery and was subsequently exonerated) talked of music ‘as a vehicle that helped maintain sanity’.